Screenshots of all replies
https://justice.hongyushen9914.workers.dev/year-list/2026/airbnb-community-center-suppression-host-replies-screenshots
Geographical distribution of hosts
All hosts (Click the profile image to switch)
Mike-And-Jane0
Airbnb Community Center profile: https://community.withairbnb.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/839431
Airbnb profile: https://www.airbnb.ca/users/show/149937183
• Name: Mike And Jane
• Country: England
• 72 Posts
• 14,639 Replies
• Trips: 6
• Reviews: 5
• 9 years on Airbnb
• Where I went to school: St Albans
• My work: Retired
• Born in the 60s
Unbelievable
Behaviors
Mike-And-Jane0 had the title
of
Top Contributor
However, due to his
disappointing
performance,
this honorary title has been
officially
removed
since Jul 24, 2026.
👎👎👎👎👎
The Airbnb Community Center - Top Contributors
Link:
https://www.airbnb.ca/help/article/1183
Top Contributors are recognized members of the Community Center who regularly share helpful insights and
answer questions from fellow hosts.
Each Top Contributor earns a special badge that appears in their Community Center profile and under their
profile image.
How to become a Top Contributor
There’s no application process. Airbnb selects Top Contributors based on consistent, meaningful participation
in the Community Center.
AI Models for Analysis
To minimize analytical bias and ensure accuracy, three independent AI systems — ChatGPT, Gemini, and Copilot
—
were used to evaluate each host / manager’s personality, psychological tendencies, and behavioral patterns.
Grey bubble is the host, blue bubble is the victim guest. The AI analyzes each reply of the host.
Select an AI mode to see the result
Final AI report for
Mike-And-Jane0
- Behavioral Traits
- Highly confident in own judgments
- Low willingness to admit error or revise stance
- Selective engagement (ignores inconvenient points)
- Prefers indirect confrontation (sarcasm, humor, reframing)
- Escalates when authority or reputation is involved
- Uses dismissal when challenged (“good luck with that”)
- Shifts to formal accusations when pressured
- Maintains composure even during conflict
- Communication Style
- Concise, controlled, and deliberate wording
- Uses sarcasm to deflect rather than engage
- Reframes others’ arguments to weaken them
- Avoids direct answers to core accusations
- Transitions from casual tone → formal tone when needed
- Strategic word choice to shape perception (“complained”, “harassment”, “pathetic”)
- Conflict Patterns
- Initial stance: authoritative and judgmental
- Mid-stage: dismissive and disengaged
- Later stage: sarcastic detachment
- Final stage: structured counterattack via authority
- Frequently reverses roles (accused → victim)
- Redirects focus from issue → opponent’s behavior
- Psychological Indicators
- Strong need to maintain control of narrative
- Sensitive to perceived pressure or demands
- Prioritizes self-consistency over correction
- Emotionally controlled but not emotionally detached
- Reacts more strongly to escalation than to facts
A controlled, confident, and strategically defensive communicator who avoids accountability through
reframing
and only escalates into formal confrontation when his position is directly challenged or threatened.
• Rigid Operational Mindset
• Confirmation Bias
• Systemic Skepticism
• Authority & Territoriality
• Defensive Deflection
• Strategic Re-Framing
• Empathy Resistance
Mike-And-Jane0 is a dogmatic, rule-bound forum veteran who relies on systemic cynicism and defensive
sarcasm
to
maintain authority while routinely rejecting evidence that challenges their initial judgments.
• Rule‑bound thinker
• Black‑and‑white worldview
• Strong ego
• Authority‑driven identity
• Low empathy
• Suspicious of guests seeking refunds
• Defensive of hosts
• Quick to assume motives
• Avoidant when challenged
• Sarcastic communication style
• Passive‑aggressive tendencies
• Emotionally inconsistent
• Projects blame onto others
• Escalates to authority when uncomfortable
• Fragile pride
• Dismissive under pressure
• Uses insults when ego is threatened
A rigid, pride‑driven forum elder who defaults to suspicion, avoids accountability, and uses sarcasm
and
authority to protect his ego when challenged.
👇👇👇👇👇
💬 Complete conversation as follow(↕ Click to
expand):
Elaine701
Airbnb Community Center profile: https://community.withairbnb.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/1035601
Airbnb profile: https://www.airbnb.ca/users/show/2052714
• Name: Elaine
• Country: Spain
• City: Balearic Islands
• 21 Posts
• 1,882 Replies
• Reviews: 192
• 14 years of hosting
• My work: Villa Son Gat, Mallorca
• Speaks English, German and Spanish
Listings:
• Exclusive Country
Getaway:
Villa Son Gat Mallorca
• Exclusive winter
getaway:
Villa Son Gat Mallorca
Unbelievable
Behaviors
Elaine701 with the title
of
Superhost
publicly said
"stay away from my place. You'll find out why."
and use the
word
"defraud"(take something illegally)
against a
victim
guest
on
Jul 6, 2026.
👎👎👎👎👎
AI Models for Analysis (Select an AI mode to see the result)
Grey bubble is the host, blue bubble is the victim guest. The AI analyzes each reply of the host.
Final AI report for
Elaine701
- Frames the discussion as guests exploiting issues to obtain refunds rather than addressing
specific
conditions
- Downplays distinctions between different problems (e.g., mice vs. spiders) by generalizing them
as
tactics
- Interprets intent (focus on “how to get a refund”) rather than engaging with factual details
presented
- Shows clear alignment with host perspectives and concerns about financial loss
- Reacts defensively to scenarios that imply guest entitlement or compensation
- Uses dismissive comparisons (mouse, spider, bird, butterfly) to minimize the severity of the
complaint
- Prioritizes perceived pattern of behavior over individual case evidence
- Positions themselves as protecting hosts from perceived abuse of the system
A host-aligned, defensive commenter who reframes specific complaints as strategic attempts to exploit
refund
policies.
• Strong In-Group Bias & Host-Centric Mentality
• Presumption of Malice & Confirmation Bias
• Sarcastic Mockery & Straw Man Tactics
• Disregard for Official Platform Policies & Authority
• Passive-Aggressive Posturing & Subtle Intimidation
• Strategic Deflection & Avoidance of Formal Accountability
Elaine701 is a host-biased forum veteran who relies on defensive sarcasm, exaggerated scenarios, and
personal
hostility to dismiss guest concerns and evade platform rules while presuming bad faith in any refund
request.
Core Traits
• Host‑centric identity
• Strong defensive reflex
• Assumes guests have bad motives
• Sarcastic communication style
• Contempt toward opposing views
• Minimizes guest problems
• Avoids policy‑based arguments
• Uses ridicule as a tool
• Projects past negative experiences
• Frames disputes as “host vs guest” battles
• Zero empathy toward guest discomfort
• Public shaming tendencies
• Passive‑aggressive tone
• Hostile humor
• Dismissive of safety concerns
• Superiority stance
• Trolling tendencies
A defensive, sarcasm‑driven veteran host who sees refund‑seeking everywhere, treats guests’ concerns
as
tactics, and uses ridicule and contempt to protect her host identity.
👇👇👇👇👇
💬 Complete conversation as follow(↕ Click to
expand):
Kia272
Airbnb Community Center profile: https://community.withairbnb.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/849266
Airbnb profile: https://www.airbnb.ca/users/show/104965289
• Name: Kia J
• Country: United States
• State: Maryland
• City: Takoma Park
• 44 Posts
• 1,529 Replies
• Reviews: 239
• 7 years of hosting
• I spend too much time: Kayaking and talking about kayaking
• I’m obsessed with: Whitewater kayaking
• What’s for breakfast: Coffee. Cold brew coffee
Listing:
• Renovated rustic & cozy
log
cabin
Unbelievable
Behaviors
Kia272 the owner of a
five-star listing
with a title of
Superhost
publicly said
"mice are a fact of life"
&
"A mouse is an inconvenience, not a threat to your life."
to a
victim guest
on Aug 8, 2023.
👎👎👎👎👎
Airbnb Community policy - Ground rules for home hosts
Link:
https://www.airbnb.ca/help/article/2895
Listing cleanliness
All listings should be clean and free of health hazards before check-in.
- Health and safety: Listings should be free of health hazards (mold, pests, etc.).
- Cleanliness: Hosts should provide listings that meet a high standard of cleanliness
(free
of
extensive dust, pet dander, dirty dishes, etc.).
- Guest turnover: Hosts should be sure to clean between every stay (do laundry, take
out
trash,
vacuum/sweep, wipe down surfaces, etc.).
Enforcing these ground rules
"Depending on the nature of the violation, Airbnb may also take other actions, such as canceling an
upcoming or
active reservation, refunding a guest from a host’s payout..."
The 🐀 statement of
Kia272 violated Airbnb policy.
AI Models for Analysis (Select an AI mode to see the result)
Grey bubble is the host, blue bubble is the victim guest. The AI analyzes each reply of the host.
Final AI report for
Kia272
- Highly experienced Airbnb host with strong platform knowledge and confidence in giving advice.
- Strong host-side perspective; tends to evaluate situations from a property-owner viewpoint
rather
than a
guest viewpoint.
- Practical and realism-focused; views occasional problems as normal parts of everyday life.
- Quick to form judgments before fully exploring all details of the situation.
- Low tolerance for what she perceives as exaggerated demands or unreasonable compensation
requests.
- Direct and blunt communication style; prioritizes expressing her opinion over maintaining
emotional
comfort.
- Uses strong wording and emotional emphasis when disagreeing.
- Shows limited empathy toward the other person's emotional experience.
- Focuses more on whether a request is reasonable than on understanding why the person feels
affected.
- Tends to minimize problems unless they reach a very high threshold of severity.
- Uses a simple classification approach: minor inconvenience vs. serious problem.
- Does not appear to consider many intermediate possibilities or complicated circumstances.
- Strong confidence in her own judgment, likely influenced by years of hosting experience.
- Communicates like an authority figure giving a correction rather than a participant exploring
different
perspectives.
- Values fairness toward hosts and proper procedure, especially allowing hosts and Airbnb time to
respond.
- Places importance on preventing excessive guest compensation claims.
- Does not actively engage with policy-based arguments about health, safety, or cleanliness
standards.
- When presented with additional information challenging her original view, she does not revise,
clarify,
or defend her position.
- Avoids prolonged disagreement once the conversation becomes more personal or argumentative.
- Shows a pattern of strong initial engagement followed by withdrawal when challenged.
- More comfortable giving opinions than participating in deep conflict resolution.
- Possible experience-based bias: her hosting background may cause her to interpret guest
complaints
more
skeptically.
- Maintains composure by disengaging rather than continuing a difficult debate.
A confident, experienced, host-oriented communicator who quickly judges situations through a practical
lens,
strongly defends her interpretation, but tends to withdraw rather than reconsider or debate when faced
with
challenging counterarguments.
• In-Group Tribalism: Automatically defends host interests and platform standards while assuming
immediate
bad
faith or greed from complaining guests.
• Hazard Minimization: Normalizes hygiene and pest issues by dismissing rodents as routine occurrences
rather
than health violations.
• Emotional Hostility: Uses confrontational, scolding language and public shaming to discourage guests
from
seeking compensation.
• Moral High-Grounding: Frames standard consumer refund attempts as personal moral failings and
entitlement.
• Strategic Evaporation: Completely abandons discussions and goes silent when facts, official platform
rulings, or logical counterarguments expose her errors.
Summary: Kia272 is an emotionally reactive host advocate who uses public scolding and hazard
minimization
to
protect host interests, only to completely withdraw into silence when contradicted by facts.
Core Traits
• Host‑identity driven
• Strong moral judgment
• Emotionally reactive
• Confrontational communication
• Low empathy toward guest experiences
• Minimizes health/safety issues
• Assumes guests exaggerate
• Quick to shame or scold
• Overconfident in her own judgment
• Rigid worldview
• Avoids accountability when challenged
• Withdraws when losing argumentative ground
• Sensitive to status and authority
• Protective of host community norms
• Sees refund requests as moral threats
• Uses silence as escape
A host‑identified, emotionally reactive community member who instinctively defends hosts, minimizes
guest
problems, and disappears completely once her moral authority is challenged.
👇👇👇👇👇
💬 Complete conversation as follow(↕ Click to
expand):
Host Support Pattern
The following users liked the reply of Kia272:
Helen3
Airbnb Community Center profile: https://community.withairbnb.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/2193
Airbnb profile: https://www.airbnb.ca/users/show/35116208
Linkedin: https://uk.linkedin.com/in/helenashley
" I am an award-winning charity & public sector communications and PR professional..."
X (Twitter): https://x.com/ethical_pr
Day job #comms . ❤️ the #NHS. Loving #Bristol. PR @SuperSupBristol
community suppers Sunset watcher.
Traveller. Live music any which way.
Bristol, England
airbnb.co.uk/rooms/29980982
Joined February 2009
• Name: Helen Ashley
• Country: England
• City: Bristol
• 62 Posts
• 21,844 Replies
• Reviews: 424
• 11 years of hosting
• My work: PR Lead @NHS
Listings:
• Cosy
Victorian
House Close to Bristol City Centre
• Secluded
Bristol
Garden Hideaway Retreat
• Cosy Victorian home 10
min
bus
Bristol city centre
• Cosy house,
St
Werburgh's, nr Bristol City Centre
AI Models for Analysis (Select an AI mode to see the result)
Grey bubble is the host, blue bubble is the victim guest. The AI analyzes each reply of the host.
Final AI report for
Helen3
- Highly experienced Airbnb community member with long-term hosting background
- Practical, solution-oriented, and focused on immediate action rather than emotional discussion
- Strong preference for official procedures and platform-based resolution channels
- Communicates in a concise, direct, and professional manner
- Shows confidence in her own judgment and experience
- Emotionally reserved; provides limited sympathy or reassurance in conflict situations
- Prioritizes safety, relocation, and problem-solving over compensation arguments
- Values consistency between a person’s words and their actions
- Believes people should make clear decisions and accept the consequences of those decisions
- Less receptive to arguments based mainly on personal frustration or victim status
- Tends to evaluate situations from a practical fairness perspective rather than an emotional
fairness
perspective
- Comfortable with strict or blunt opinions when she believes someone is avoiding responsibility
- Uses indirect communication methods (such as likes) to express agreement rather than engaging in
long
debates
- Avoids prolonged arguments and disengages when she believes the correct solution has already
been
provided
- Displays a “professional moderator” style: calm, structured, and focused on resolution
- Likely influenced by her PR/public-sector background: reputation, procedure, and responsible
communication appear important to her
- May unintentionally appear cold or unsympathetic because she prioritizes efficiency over
emotional
validation
- Shows some alignment with host-side concerns, but not necessarily because she ignores guest
problems;
rather, she emphasizes guest responsibility after a problem occurs
Helen3 is a pragmatic, experienced, process-driven communicator who values responsibility,
consistency,
and
practical solutions, but her emotionally detached and strict approach can make her appear less
sympathetic
toward people who feel harmed.
• Professional Image Management & PR Mindset
• Pragmatic & Procedure-First Orientation
• Covert In-Group Host Alignment
• Low-Risk Emotional Expression (Passive Liking)
• Boundary Enforcement & Controlled Engagement
Helen3 is a composed, image-conscious PR professional who maintains procedural neutrality in her
direct
communication while quietly endorsing the host community's stance through low-risk passive
interactions.
Core Traits
• Procedural thinker
• Host‑aligned perspective
• Low empathy toward guest issues
• Emotionally detached communication
• Prefers simple cause‑and‑effect narratives
• Judgmental toward persistent complaints
• Supports confrontational comments
• Group‑loyal to host community
• Avoids discussing policy details
• Assumes guest responsibility over host responsibility
• Dismissive of guest frustration
• Comfortable reinforcing harsh social norms
• Conflict‑minimizing but blame‑shifting
• Morally aligned with “don’t complain, just act” mindset
A procedural, host‑loyal community veteran who stays emotionally detached and openly supports harsh,
judgmental replies toward guests she believes are over‑complaining or seeking excessive compensation.
👇👇👇👇👇
💬 Complete conversation as follow(↕ Click to
expand):
Helen744
Airbnb Community Center profile: https://community.withairbnb.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/643668
Airbnb profile: https://www.airbnb.ca/users/show/50844171
• Name: Helen M
• Country: Australia
• City: Redan
• 6 Posts
• 2,988 Replies
• Reviews: 4
• 11 years on Airbnb
• Where I went to school: Daylesford
• Where I've always wanted to go: Everywhere
• I’m obsessed with: Books
Unbelievable
Behaviors
Helen744 with
11 years of experience
on Airbnb simply said
"mouse playing 'peek a boo' with you"
to
a
victim guest
on
Aug 10, 2023.
👎👎👎👎👎
AI Models for Analysis (Select an AI mode to see the result)
Grey bubble is the host, blue bubble is the victim guest. The AI analyzes each reply of the host.
Final AI report for
Helen744
• Dismissive and somewhat patronizing in tone
• Tends to generalize based on prior experience with guests/hosts
• Skeptical of complaints; leans toward assuming possible guest exaggeration or manipulation
• Uses anecdotal evidence to support arguments rather than addressing the specific case directly
• Positions herself as more experienced/knowledgeable (authority stance)
• Downplays the severity of the issue by reframing it (e.g., “peek a boo”)
• Shifts focus from the reported problem to broader patterns (e.g., guest fraud, pest control
routines)
• Defensive of hosts and the hosting system
• Indirectly questions the credibility of the complainant
• Uses a calm but subtly dismissive and invalidating communication style
A skeptical, experience-driven communicator who downplays specific complaints while defending hosts
and
questioning guest credibility.
• Paternalistic Pragmatism: Offers advice from an authoritative, experienced perspective, focusing on
operational realities while dismissing emotional distress or situational constraints.
• In-Group Host Loyalty: Automatically defaults to defending host practices and property standards,
framing
hosts as diligent victims of routine maintenance challenges.
• Systemic Cynicism: Focuses heavily on potential guest dishonesty and fraud (such as fake pest claims
or
planted insects) to explain host skepticism.
• Dismissive Facetiousness: Uses lighthearted phrasing and sarcasm (such as "peek a boo") to minimize
serious
pest allegations and defuse conflict.
• Anecdotal Generalization: Relies on personal assumptions and generalized anecdotes about host
operations
rather than evaluating specific user evidence or platform policy.
Helen744 is a long-standing forum contributor who uses paternalistic pragmatism, host-centric bias,
and
systemic cynicism regarding guest motives to downplay pest complaints and defend host practices.
Core Traits
• Host‑centric worldview
• Strong suspicion toward guests
• Defensive posture
• Minimizes guest problems
• Sarcastic communication
• Facetious tone
• Projects past negative experiences
• In‑group loyalty to hosts
• Low empathy toward distressed guests
• Moral framing of guest behavior
• Authority‑corrective tone
• Assumes guests exaggerate or fabricate issues
• Reputation‑focused mindset
• Normalizes host mistakes, pathologizes guest complaints
• Emotionally detached problem framing
A defensive, host‑aligned community elder who instinctively doubts guests, minimizes their problems,
and
reframes conflicts through her loyalty to hosts and her past negative experiences rather than the
facts
in
front of her.
👇👇👇👇👇
💬 Complete conversation as follow(↕ Click to
expand):
Community Manager Support Pattern
The following users liked the replies of Helen744:
Jenny
Community Manager ❓❗
Airbnb Community Center profile: https://community.withairbnb.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/1198241
Airbnb profile: https://www.airbnb.ca/users/show/450593595
• Name: Jenny
• Country: Scotland
• City: Galashiels
• 72 Posts
• 2,495 Replies
• Reviews: 0
• 4 years on Airbnb
• My work: Community Manager
• Pets: My old gentleman cat, Walter.
• Born in the 80s
• I spend too much time: Reading books!
• Speaks English
• I’m obsessed with: Live music.
⚠️ Unbelievable Behaviors
⁉️ This Community Manager publicly supported the statement of Helen744 "You describe these mice as 'a mouse ' as if only one mouse is
playing
'peek a boo'with you." against the victim guest.
Hannah1263
Airbnb Community Center profile: https://community.withairbnb.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/1546136
Airbnb profile: https://www.airbnb.ca/users/show/51865
• Name: Hannah
• Country: United States
• State: West Virginia
• City: Hambleton
• 0 Post
• 1 Reply
• Reviews: 303
• 14 years of hosting
• My work: Intl. tour guide
• What makes my home unique: The natural light is dreamy.
• I’m obsessed with: Travel and new experiences
Listings:
• Sky View on
the
Rail Trail
• Cozy Camper on
the
Rail Trail
Unbelievable
Behaviors
Hannah1263 with the title of
Superhost
joked about
"cancer causing pesticides"
to
a
victim guest
on
Dec 17, 2024.
👎👎👎👎👎
AI Models for Analysis (Select an AI mode to see the result)
Grey bubble is the host, blue bubble is the victim guest. The AI analyzes each reply of the host.
Final AI report for
Hannah1263
• Dismissive and contempt-driven tone
• Uses sarcasm to undermine opposing views
• Strong in-group bias (host-aligned thinking)
• Quickly generalizes individuals into negative categories
• Low empathy toward complaints or discomfort
• Defensive when perceiving criticism of hosts
• Relies on exaggeration and mockery instead of facts
• Frames others as inexperienced or naive
• Prefers judgment over problem-solving
• Emotionally reactive rather than neutral or analytical
A defensive and dismissive communicator who relies on sarcasm and bias to invalidate others rather
than
engaging with the situation objectively.
• In-Group Host Bias & Defensive Posture
• Hazard Minimization & Normalization of Pest Issues
• Dismissive Sarcasm & Emotional Invalidation
• Straw Man Fallacy & Exaggeration of Guest Claims
• False Dilemma Fallacy
• Condescending & Patronizing Stance
• Host Burnout & Emotional Venting
Hannah is a host-biased veteran host who uses dismissive sarcasm, exaggeration, and patronizing logic
to
invalidate guest complaints and vent built-up hostility toward refund requests.
Personality & Psychological Traits
• Strong Host Identity
• Defensive Attitude
• Low Empathy Toward Guests
• Sarcastic Communication Style
• Moral Superiority Tone
• High Irritation Threshold
• Projection of Past Negative Guest Experiences
• Belief in “Toughness” as Virtue
• Minimization of Safety Concerns
• Black‑and‑White Thinking
• Host‑Community Loyalty
• Quick Judgment of Guest Motives
• Low Tolerance for Complaints
• Preference for Naturalistic Framing (“critters are normal”)
• Dismissive of Emotional Reactions
• Self‑image as Experienced and Worldly
• Implicit Belief That Guests Exaggerate
• Mild Contempt Toward “Sensitive” People
• Conflict Style: Mocking Instead of Problem‑Solving
Behavioral Patterns
• Uses Sarcasm as First Response
• Frames Guest Complaints as Personal Attacks
• Normalizes Problems to Avoid Accountability
• Shifts Blame Toward Guest Sensitivity
• Uses Ridicule to Diminish Guest Credibility
• Positions Herself as “Realistic” and Guest as “Naive”
• Responds Emotionally Rather Than Logically
• Generalizes One Guest Into a Category
• Prioritizes Host Reputation Over Guest Experience
• Shows Host‑Side Solidarity
Social Dynamics & Power Orientation
• Host‑Dominant Power Position
• Views Guest Complaints as Threats
• Uses Social Pressure (“guests like you…”)
• Attempts to Shame Guest Into Silence
A sarcastic, defensive, host‑loyal personality who minimizes guest concerns, projects past
frustrations,
and
responds with mocking superiority rather than empathy or problem‑solving.
👇👇👇👇👇
💬 Complete conversation as follow(↕ Click to
expand):